Showing posts with label quack medical devices. Show all posts
Showing posts with label quack medical devices. Show all posts

Saturday, September 01, 2018

What can we learn from "Quack" Medicines, Medical Devices, and Therapy?


What's the difference between Alternative Medical Devices and Quack Medical Devices?  It depends on who you ask!
  • Satisfied patients who have found relief in such devices will say the devices are Alternative/Complementary Therapy, that maybe even a doctor recommended. (Anecdotal Evidence)
  • Purists who ignore Anecdotal Evidence and only accept Scientific Evidence will say the devices are Quackery.
Like it or not, Alternative/Complementary Medical (CAM) Devices are here to stay, despite being called Quackery, by some.  This is shown by the huge, and growing, CAM market.


 

Okay, now that we have that out of the way, here's a list of Complementary/Alternative Medicine/Therapy/etc.

Now to the learning parts:
  • First and most important - Some past/present CAM modalities are just not safe.  Why not make them safe for patient use - via redesign, instructions, etc.?


  • Healthcare professionals, e.g. doctors, could help patients find relief from symptoms when science does not provide relief - if they wanted to and were not bound by peer ethics.


Quiz - Is it more important to provide "relief in any way" to patients, especially those with chronic symptoms, e.g. pain,  or only provide scientifically proven methods of relief?


Clue - Try taking a copper magnetic bracelet away from a patient finding relief from pain from this bracelet.


There you have it.  Let's get to work!

References -

The placebo effect in alternative medicine: can the ... - NCBI - NIH

Placebo effect behind many natural cures - Health - Alternative ...

Placebo Effects: Biological, Clinical and Ethical Advances - NCBI - NIH

The ethics of the placebo in clinical practice | Journal of Medical Ethics

Is Alternative Medicine Just a Placebo? | Psychology Today

Do medical devices have enhanced placebo effects? - Semantic Schola

Welcome to The Museum of Questionable Medical Devices Online ...

Quack Medical - Spark Museum

Ridiculous Vintage Quack Medical Devices | Medical Billing

Alternative "Quack" Medical Devices

The Big Quack Attack: Medical Devices - Device Watch

Part IV: Regulating Cosmetics, Devices, and Veterinary Medicine After ...

The Literature of Quackery: Amusement and Understanding - OHSU

Medical Quackery!

The Quack Doctor

Questionable Device Index - Quackwatch

museum of quack medical electrotherapy instruments - W1TP ...

Quackery - Wikipedia

Anecdotal evidence - Wikipedia

Scientific evidence - Wikipedia

Safe Use of Complementary Health Products and Practices | NCCIH

The other side of the coin: safety of complementary and alternative ...

The placebo effect is amplified when doctors appear likeable and ...

Should Doctors Use More Placebos? - Medscape

Snake Oil, Hustlers and Hambones: The American Medicine Show

 

 

 

Article is for information only and is not medical advice.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Monday, September 22, 2014

Consider Recycling Medical Devices as “Alternative or Complementary” Therapy Tools



A New and Unique Way to Recycle Broken or Obsolete Medical Devices


Consider Recycling Medical Devices as “Alternative or Complementary” Therapy Tools

Medical devices and equipment become obsolete too. Sometimes, these devices are recycled for use in poverty areas, which is very good. 

Some equipment cannot be refurbished for further use, however. What happens to those devices? 
 
Usually, medical devices that cannot be refurbished are destroyed. This seems like a waste to me.
Could these devices be converted to placebo healing devices? The devices would not have to work; they just have to look like they work.
 
The Placebo Effect is well known. Whether anyone likes it or not, the placebo response is a part of any medicine or medical treatment. Much of alternative, complementary, and/or integrative medicine seems to be the placebo effect. 

A device does not have to be in working condition for the placebo effect to work. The patient just has to believe, even a little, that it is working for the placebo effect to start. 

Therefore, please consider recycling unusable medical devices into "healing machines", instead of destroying them

Below are some thoughts on how to implement such a plan, if so desired. 

1. First, check around and see if the above is legal in your locality. In addition, check if you are legally able to heal in your locality. Many areas of the world require a license to "practice medicine". Also, see if there is a demand for placebo powered healing machines, before you go to too much trouble. With legal clearance, go ahead with below.
2. Thoroughly clean and disinfect the device.
3. Disable the devices electrically and mechanically. Remove any spring tensions, etc. You do not want to hurt someone while trying to heal them.
4. Remove manufacturer labels or anything to show that made the device initially.
5. Now, that you have a "dead" device comes the fun part.
6. Augment the device with battery powered lights, sounds, smells, vibrations, etc. Really make it look like it is doing something. Make it impressive. Have others review the emotional impact. See if they are "wowed". Again, it should not do anything, but just look good.
7. A big part of the placebo response is the healing ritual. Develop a performance surrounding the healing machine. Involve the patient in the healing procedure, if possible. Make it believable.
8. At the end of the performance, reassure them of the healing process. Give them a small token as a remembrance of this healing process. If symptoms recur, ask them to rub the object to remind them of the ongoing healing. 

Since this a new concept, it might take a while to catch on, if at all. This might be a new and exciting field for biomedical engineers. Most medical designs do not consider the Placebo Effect at all, yet about 30% of healing is attributed to the Placebo Effect, the "Will to Live", and so on. 

Takeaways:
  • Broken or obsolete medical devices could be recycled into Alternative or Complementary Healing Devices.
  • Biomedical engineers could design to maximize the Placebo Effect, and therefore maximize overall healing efficiency.
  • A completely new medical industry lies in wait.
For more information:
Disclaimer - Article is for informational use only and is not medical and/or legal advice. Seek professional help, as needed or wanted.